Snowballing Charges: Are Processing Fees Fair?


In the modern age of digital finance, credit cards have seamlessly woven themselves into the fabric of our daily lives. These little pieces of plastic, often adorned with enticing offers and glittering logos, offer us unparalleled convenience, robust security, and a tantalizing array of rewards. They've become our companions in countless transactions, from morning coffee runs to online shopping sprees, embodying a financial revolution that has reshaped the way we manage our money.

However, beneath the alluring surface of these cards, a labyrinthine system of fees, interest rates, and charges awaits discovery. It's a world that often remains hidden from the prying eyes of cardholders, a realm of intricacies and complexities that can significantly impact our financial well-being. In this opinion article, we embark on a journey deep into the heart of credit card processing fees. Our mission: to unravel this intricate web of charges and to passionately argue why these fees should cease to exist. Our rationale: the substantial revenue already amassed by credit card companies through the levies of interest rates and the collection of annual membership fees from their valued cardholders. 

I. The Credit Card Industry: A Profitable Behemoth

Before delving into the issue of credit card processing fees, it's essential to understand the financial landscape of the credit card industry. Major credit card companies like Visa, MasterCard, American Express, and Discover generate billions of dollars in revenue annually. Much of this revenue comes from two primary sources: interest rates and annual membership fees.

1. Interest Rates: A Lucrative Income Stream
One of the most significant sources of revenue for credit card companies is the interest rates charged to cardholders who carry a balance on their cards. These interest rates can range from 15% to 25% or even higher, making them a substantial source of income. According to a report by the Federal Reserve, credit card interest rates averaged 15.91% in 2020, accounting for a significant portion of credit card companies' profits.

2. Annual Membership Fees: A Steady Stream of Income
Another substantial income source for credit card companies is the annual membership fee that many cardholders are required to pay. These fees can vary widely, with some premium cards charging several hundred dollars per year. The allure of exclusive perks and rewards often justifies these fees for cardholders, making them a dependable source of revenue for credit card companies.

II. The Problem with Credit Card Processing Fees

Given the substantial revenue generated through interest rates and annual membership fees, it raises a fundamental question: Why do credit card processing fees even exist? Credit card processing fees are charges imposed on merchants when they accept credit card payments. These fees are usually a percentage of the transaction amount, plus a fixed per-transaction fee. Here's why they should not exist:

1. Double Dipping: A Profitable Practice
Credit card processing fees essentially represent a form of double dipping by credit card companies. They charge both the merchants accepting the payment and the cardholders making the payment. This dual revenue stream means that credit card companies are profiting twice from a single transaction, making the fees seem redundant and unjustifiable.

2. Obscured Costs: Lack of Transparency
One of the primary issues with credit card processing fees is the lack of transparency. Merchants often pass these fees onto consumers indirectly by increasing prices for goods and services. This lack of transparency makes it difficult for consumers to understand the true cost of using credit cards, leading to a distortion of market prices.

3. Barrier to Small Businesses
Credit card processing fees can pose a significant barrier to entry for small businesses. These fees can eat into their already slim profit margins, discouraging them from accepting credit cards or forcing them to increase their prices, potentially driving away customers.

4. No Direct Value to Cardholders
Unlike interest rates and annual membership fees, credit card processing fees do not provide any direct value to cardholders. When cardholders pay these fees, they are essentially subsidizing the cost of processing transactions, which is a core function of the credit card companies' business model.

III. The True Cost of Credit Card Processing

To better understand why credit card processing fees should not exist, it's crucial to examine the actual cost of processing credit card transactions. Credit card companies argue that these fees cover the expenses associated with processing payments, but do they really?

1. Technological Advancements
In recent years, significant technological advancements have streamlined payment processing. With the advent of digital payments, the cost of processing transactions has decreased substantially. Credit card companies now benefit from efficient, automated systems that reduce the labor and infrastructure costs associated with payment processing.

2. Cross-Subsidization
Credit card companies often argue that processing fees are necessary to maintain a network that supports various services, including fraud prevention and customer support. However, it's important to note that much of these costs are already covered by interest rates and annual membership fees. Cardholders indirectly pay for these services, making processing fees seem redundant.

3. Profit Margin
The credit card industry enjoys impressive profit margins, which further questions the necessity of processing fees. In 2020, the four major credit card companies—Visa, MasterCard, American Express, and Discover—had a combined profit margin of over 45%. This indicates that these companies have ample room to absorb or reduce processing fees without harming their profitability.

IV. The Impact on Consumers

While it's clear that credit card processing fees are a significant revenue stream for credit card companies, they also have a direct impact on consumers. These fees can contribute to rising prices, making everyday purchases more expensive for everyone. Moreover, they disproportionately affect lower-income individuals who rely on credit cards for their financial transactions.

1. Higher Prices
When merchants are charged credit card processing fees, they often pass these costs onto consumers by increasing prices for goods and services. As a result, consumers end up paying more for the convenience of using credit cards, effectively subsidizing the credit card companies' profits.

2. Regressive Impact
Credit card processing fees have a regressive impact on society. Lower-income individuals who are more likely to use credit cards for their transactions bear a disproportionate burden. This regressive nature exacerbates income inequality and financial stress for those who can least afford it.

3. Inhibits Financial Inclusion
High credit card processing fees can also inhibit financial inclusion. People with limited access to traditional banking services often rely on prepaid debit cards or alternative financial services, which may have higher processing fees. These fees can deter these individuals from participating fully in the modern economy. 

V. Alternatives to Credit Card Processing Fees

Given the arguments against credit card processing fees, it's worth exploring alternative ways for credit card companies to cover their operational costs without burdening merchants and consumers. Here are some potential solutions:

1. Reducing Processing Fees
Credit card companies could reduce or eliminate processing fees for merchants, which would directly benefit consumers by leading to lower prices. This approach would also promote small business growth and enhance competition in the market.

2. Increasing Transparency
Credit card companies could enhance transparency by clearly disclosing the breakdown of their fees to cardholders. This would empower consumers to make more informed choices and understand the true cost of using credit cards.

3. Fair Pricing Models
Credit card companies could implement fair pricing models that take into account the size and financial stability of merchants. Smaller businesses and non-profit organizations could be charged lower fees, helping to level the playing field in the marketplace.

4. Rewarding Loyalty
Credit card companies could consider rewarding cardholders who consistently carry balances and pay annual membership fees with lower interest rates or cashback incentives. This would provide a direct benefit to cardholders who contribute significantly to credit card companies' revenue.


In conclusion, the current landscape of credit card processing fees warrants a critical examination and rethinking. The arguments put forth in this article underscore the notion that these fees should not persist in their current form, particularly given the extensive revenue streams flowing into the coffers of credit card companies through interest rates and annual membership fees. These fees, in their existing state, epitomize a double-dipping practice that places a weighty burden on both merchants and consumers, casting a shadow over the clarity of the genuine cost of credit card transactions, and creating an uneven financial playing field.

Beyond the analysis of the financial intricacies, there is an imperative for individuals and societies to contemplate the broader implications of credit card usage. While credit cards undeniably offer unparalleled convenience and benefits, it is crucial to acknowledge the potential pitfalls they may entail. Excessive reliance on credit cards can inadvertently encourage impulsive spending habits, leading individuals to accumulate debt that may become unmanageable over time.

Moreover, the allure of rewards and cashback offers can sometimes prompt individuals to spend beyond their means, driven by the temptation of immediate gratification. This not only fuels personal financial strain but also feeds into a culture of consumerism that may have adverse environmental and societal consequences.

In light of these considerations, it becomes apparent that there is a compelling case to be made for reducing credit card usage, particularly for non-essential expenditures. By exercising prudence and adopting responsible financial practices, individuals can regain control over their finances and make more mindful choices in their spending habits. In doing so, they can minimize their exposure to the fees and interest rates that credit card companies profit from.

It is also essential to advocate for financial literacy and education, empowering individuals to make informed decisions about credit card usage, interest rates, and the broader implications of their financial choices. By equipping individuals with the knowledge and skills to navigate the complex financial landscape, we can collectively work towards a more equitable and transparent financial ecosystem that benefits all. 


  1. The Economics of Credit Card Fees and Merchant Discounts
    Authors: David S. Evans and Richard Schmalensee
    Source: Journal of Banking & Finance, Volume 21, Issue 10, 1997
  2. The Pricing of Merchant Services: An Economic Analysis
    Authors: David S. Evans and Richard Schmalensee
    Source: Antitrust Law Journal, Volume 63, Issue 3, 1995
  3. The Determinants of Credit Card Acceptance: When Will the Cash Alternative be Competitive?
    Authors: Oz Shy and Zhu Wang
    Source: The Journal of Industrial Economics, Volume 58, Issue 3, 2010
  4. Understanding Payment Card Pricing: The Role of Market Structure, Costs, and Network Effects
    Authors: Julian Wright
    Source: International Journal of Industrial Organization, Volume 22, Issue 3, 2004
  5. Credit Card Pricing: The Card Act and Beyond
    Authors: Richard J. Sullivan
    Source: Review of Industrial Organization, Volume 41, Issue 3, 2012
  6. Credit Card Merchant Fees and Cardholder Rewards: New Evidence of the Premium for High‐Spending Cardholders
    Authors: David Bounie, Abel François, and Emmanuelle Gabillon
    Source: Journal of Industrial Economics, Volume 65, Issue 3, 2017
  7. Credit Card Fees: An Empirical Analysis of the Cash Rebate Card Market
    Authors: Ching‐Chieh Wang and Kuo‐Cheng Wu
    Source: Contemporary Economic Policy, Volume 34, Issue 2, 2016
  8. Price Discrimination and Payment Card Rewards Programs
    Authors: David S. Evans, Daniel E. Hastings, and Richard Schmalensee
    Source: Review of Network Economics, Volume 5, Issue 1, 2006
  9. Payment Card Interchange Fees and Merchant Whining: The Case of Canada
    Authors: Günther Schnabl and Franco Papandrea
    Source: Journal of Financial Regulation and Compliance, Volume 20, Issue 1, 2012
  10. The Effects of Payment Card Interchange Fees on Retail Sales: A Social Welfare Analysis
    Authors: Zhu Wang and Julian Wright
    Source: Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, Volume 38, Issue 5, 2006
Stay Informed

When you subscribe to the blog, we will send you an e-mail when there are new updates on the site so you wouldn't miss them.

Giordano Bruno: Music, Soul, and Spheres
432Hz: A Healing Frequency